Choose Between Crete Or Santorini – Santorini Vs Crete

Chasing the Donkey may include affiliate links - if you decide to make a purchase through these links, we receive a commission without any additional cost to you. Disclaimer & privacy policy.
Post author SJ

Written by our local expert SJ

Sarah-Jane has lived in Croatia for 10+ years. SJ, as she is known, has been traveling the Balkans & beyond since 2000. She now shares her passion for traveling with her husband & kids.

With more than a hundred inhabited islands and literally thousands of other islands and islets, deciding which Greek Islands to visit can be challenging.

In this post, we’ll help you choose between two of Greece’s most popular and beautiful islands: Crete and Santorini—or Crete or Santorini based on our many years of experience exploring the islands.

In a rush and just want to know how to choose between Crete or Santorini? Here is what we think you should know:

Crete Santorini
More affordable & family friendly Luxurious, romantic destination
Fantastic variety of activities Foodie approved cuisine
Dotted with historic sites Spectacular sunsets & beaches

Choosing between Santorini or Crete can feel like travel torture. “Why can’t I just visit both?!” you might scream at your guidebook, favorite Greece travel blog, or flabbergasted partner. And while, yes, it is totally possible to visit both Santorini and Crete on the same trip, sometimes time constraints make it practically impossible to do so.

Don’t fear or fret, though. A visit to “just” Santorini or “only” Crete is absolutely worth it, too. You don’t have to visit both islands to have an unforgettable Greek island holiday. Each of these islands is stunning in its own way, whether it’s thanks to beautiful Greek beaches, ancient historic sites, breathtaking cave hotels, or vibrant nightlife. There’s plenty to see and do on both islands.

Let’s go! We’ll discuss each island destination separately to help you settle your inner doubts about the Crete versus Santorini question. Hopefully, this overview will help you how to choose between Crete or Santorini.

Keep reading below for our in-depth analysis on weighing up Crete vs. Santorini

Why Choose Crete Vs. Santorini

How To Get From Santorini To Crete - Agios Nikolaos, Crete

Crete is Greece’s biggest island and one of the largest islands in the Mediterranean. A super-popular island destination, this is a place where you could spend a week or more exploring beaches and ancient sites.

Be aware that Crete is a pretty large island, though, and you might need a rental car or join some kind of guided tour to get around and see the top sights beyond the coastal cities.

The two main cities on Crete are Chania and Heraklion, both of which have transportation connections to Athens and other Greek Islands. Additionally, because it’s so easily accessible from the Greek mainland, especially from the port of Piraeus, Crete is a popular vacation destination among local Greeks.

On Crete, you can spend your time enjoying epic beaches like Vai Beach, Preveli Beach, or Elafonisi, visiting the superb Heraklion Archaeological Museum, seeing the Monastery of Arkadi, hiking to Mount Ida, and so many other fun activities.

A mountain range crosses this mostly rocky island from east to west, offering fantastic hiking and other outdoor recreation while stunning sandy beaches line its shore. You’ll find many accommodation options throughout the island, from budget hotels to luxury resorts.

Why You Should Visit Crete

Guide To Where To Stay In Crete, Greece - Elafonisi Lagoon

Is Crete worth visiting? Well, yes! Yes, it is. In fact, this is one of the most incredible destinations in the entire Mediterranean Sea. That’s a strong statement I don’t make lightly—it’s true. There are many reasons why you might choose Crete over Santorini.

Reasons Not To Visit Crete

While I typically don’t like focusing on the cons of things—I’m an “always look on the bright side of life” kind of person—there are a few reasons why it might be better for you to visit Santorini instead of Crete. Keep them in mind while choosing between Santorini or Crete.

  • Crete is a huge island, by far the largest in Greece, and ideally, you’d need one or even two weeks to explore it fully. For most people, this would mean dedicating their entire holiday in Greece—or a large part of it—to one island. Perhaps not the best idea if you’d like to see other parts of Greece, too
  • Because Crete is so big, you’ll need your own car or use public transportation to get around. This increases your budget for a proper Crete vacation
  • If you’re limited on time, you’ll need to travel to Crete by plane from the Greek mainland. Ferries from Piraeus take at least 6.5 hours but often last 10+ hours
  • While some great accommodations cater to couples in Crete, Santorini wins the “romance contest” hands down. There’s arguably no more romantic destination in Greece than Santorini

How To Get To Crete

Greece Travel Blog_How To Choose Between Santorini Or Crete Greece

Crete is well-connected to the Greek mainland, particularly to the huge port of Piraeus, which is one of Europe’s busiest passenger ports. There are also numerous ferry routes between Crete and other nearby islands. Crete is easily reached by ferry from the Cyclades island group, including Santorini but also Mykonos and Naxos.

Additionally, there are daily direct flights between Athens International Airport and airports on Crete, such as Chania and Heraklion.

Brands We Use And Trust


Why Choose Santorini Vs. Crete

Easter In Greece - Santorini Church

Upon arrival to Santorini, you will be mesmerized by the impressive views of the volcano, in striking contrast with the deep blue color of the sea surrounding the island. Home to the most spectacular sunsets over the Aegean Sea, Santorini is an excellent place for a couple’s getaway, a romantic escape, or even a honeymoon.

Santorini is the remnant of a volcanic caldera, formed after one of the largest volcanic eruptions in recorded history—the Minoan eruption—which might have been responsible for the decline of the once-thriving Minoan civilization in nearby Crete. The Santorini volcano is still active today.

Fun fact: the Minoan eruption in what is now Santorini might have been the origin of the Atlantis legend!

That little bit of history is just to set the scene. While there are some fascinating historic sites on the island, Santorini is now most famous for its striking white houses.

Especially the cliffside town of Oia is known worldwide for its photogenic cliffside houses and spectacular sunsets. This is where you’ll find many of the best Santorini cave hotels and Santorini cave villas. On the other hand, the capital of Santorini is Fira, built high atop a coastal cliff overlooking the sea and boasting beautiful white buildings.

Why You Should Visit Santorini

Just look at a picture of Santorini, and you’ll know precisely why you should go and visit this breathtaking volcanic island. It’s almost impossibly beautiful. Here are some other reasons why you might choose Santorini over Crete.

  • Santorini is unquestionably one of the most romantic destinations in Europe if not the entire world. Its photogenic whitewashed hillside villages are delightful to stroll through, and the views are exceptional
  • In fact, those views on Santorini are so amazing they deserve their own bullet point. Especially the northern village of Oia is famous for its sunsets. You can watch the sun dip behind the Mediterranean Sea while enjoying a glass of local wine on your private balcony
  • You can stay in a cave hotel in Santorini. Yes, you read that right. The volcanic rocks on Santorini’s hilly coasts are quite carvable—is that a word?—and many hotels feature cave rooms, suites, and apartments. They typically feature whitewashed, domed rooms and hallways, as well as private hot tubs and balconies. Staying in a Santorini cave hotel is one of the world’s most incredible travel experiences
  • Arguably more so than Crete, Santorini has become a gastronomical destination, too. On this small island, you can enjoy traditional Greek platters at taverns, sip on exquisite wines or refreshing cocktails, and indulge in fusion foods at high-end restaurants
  • It’s a place to wind down and relax. Just because there’s relatively little to do here—especially when compared with Crete—Santorini is a phenomenal place to kick back with a good book, enjoy each other’s company, and sit and take in the epic views. Although it’s very “Instagrammable,” Santorini is also a top location for that “digital detox” we all need

Reasons Not To Visit Santorini

While there are many, many, many reasons to visit Santorini, this island might not be ideal for your specific holiday under certain circumstances.

  • Santorini is significantly smaller than Crete, and, as such, there’s much less to do in terms of activities. There are some interesting tours to join and wineries to visit, but this pales in comparison with the diversity and the sheer number of activity options offered by Crete
  • Although it’s a super-romantic destination, Santorini may not be ideal for families with children. Many accommodations cater to couples; few focus on traveling families. (However, we do have a guide to discovering Santorini with kids if you opt to take the whole family!)
  • Santorini is a destination visited mainly by international tourists, not by local Greeks people. This means that prices are higher in Santorini than they are in Crete. In short, Santorini is not a budget destination
  • Santorini can feel very crowded in the high season, especially when a cruise ship has docked in the port

How To Get To Santorini

Getting to Santorini is pretty straightforward and possible in several ways. The fastest option is flying to Santorini, which you can do from Athens and cities in other countries. In addition to direct flights from Athens, there are direct flights to Santorini from, for example, Rome, Paris, and London as well.

Santorini has excellent links with other islands, including Naxos, Mykonos, Ios, Paros, and Crete, if you’d instead take the ferry. There are also regular ferries from Piraeus to Santorini.

How To Choose Santorini Or Crete: Accommodation

Are There Sandy Beaches In Greece - Balos beach at Crete island in Greece

Generally speaking, hotels in Crete are slightly cheaper than those in Santorini because they’re popular among locals, and there are simply more. Crete’s high supply and high demand keep prices relatively low, while Santorini’s limited supply and extremely high demand increase rates significantly.

Crete is the better choice if you’re traveling as a family with small(er) kids. This large island has excellent family-friendly hotels and fun beaches. On the other hand, Santorini is popular among couples, particularly honeymooners, thanks to its breathtaking sunsets, scenic villages, and spectacular cave hotels.

Hopefully, this Crete vs. Santorini guide helped you consider Crete vs. Santorini. Whatever choice you make, each island has lots to offer and is a world-class holiday destination. Enjoy your trip!

Comments (2)

  1. Thanks for this great information. We are traveling in March – would one island be preferable to the other in March? And, do you think 3 nights in Crete and 2 nights in Santorini would be doable? (Adult couple, no kids).

    1. If it were me I’d stick to Crete. If you do want to go Santorini for 2 nights stay in the capital of Fira, as seasonal businesses in Santorini are mostly closed in March, but here you will find some restaurants open as locals live there.

      Last March I was on Corfu Island and loved having so much to ourselves, though all the beach bars were closed, you can still walk along the beaches or relax with a good book.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Move This Adventure To Your Inbox & Get An Instant Freebie

Subscribe To Unlock Your FREE Customizable Travel Packing List & All Our Best Tips!